The crowded
Law offices are 7.6 times the typical county, and salons, restaurants and physician offices run between 3.4 and 4.0 times. A new entrant must choose a narrow specialty or a narrow area to be seen.
RankGuarantee™ SEO
Local landing pages built in volume, for every city you serve.
Rank on page 1 for 100+ local keywordsRank for 100+ local keywordsRank for 100+ Local Keywords
Included in all Organic Growth plansFree in every Organic Growth plan $1,495/moOrganic Growth
SEO, Google Maps, and AI search (GEO) working as one plan.
SEO, Google Maps & AI search in one planSEO, Maps & AI in one planSEO, Google Maps & AI Optimization
Includes RankGuarantee™ + a custom websiteRankGuarantee™ + website included $895/moPaid Ads
Google, Bing & Meta campaigns managed end-to-end for fast leads.
Google, Bing & Meta Ads for fast leadsGoogle, Bing & Meta AdsGoogle, Bing & Meta Ads Management
Get results in days, not monthsResults in days, not monthsThree different questions
This page reads the County Business Patterns counts, which cover employer locations only, so sole proprietors are not included. Three questions are worth asking of any trade. How crowded is it, measured as locations for each 10,000 residents against the typical county of 20,000 or more residents? How big are the firms, measured by the share with fewer than ten staff and the count with twenty or more? And has the trade grown or shrunk since the 2017 count? The five years between the two counts include the pandemic, which hit offices, restaurants and medical practices differently.
Population matters too. The 2023 Census estimate for New York County is 1,597,451 residents, which is 5.7 percent below the 2020 count. A business that relies on the resident base should not assume growth, and one that relies on the daytime crowd should watch the weekday population, which is near 4 million. Together, the Manhattan numbers explain why marketing in New York County is a matter of standing out in a crowded field and not of waiting for more customers to arrive.
The full count
| Trade | Locations | Per 10,000 residents | Versus typical county | Under 10 staff | With 20+ staff | Change since 2017 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Residential remodelers | 511 | 3.2 | 1 times | 82 of 100 | 37 | +1.6 percent |
| Roofing contractors | 6 | 0 | 0 times | 50 of 100 | 0 | -33.3 percent |
| Electrical contractors | 221 | 1.4 | 0.6 times | 57 of 100 | 54 | -4.7 percent |
| Plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors | 226 | 1.4 | 0.4 times | 69 of 100 | 33 | +3.2 percent |
| Insurance agencies and brokerages | 630 | 3.9 | 1.1 times | 79 of 100 | 83 | -15.2 percent |
| Real estate agents and brokers | 1,405 | 8.8 | 3.2 times | 89 of 100 | 75 | +0.1 percent |
| Law offices | 3,550 | 22.2 | 7.6 times | 80 of 100 | 445 | -8 percent |
| Accounting and CPA firms | 544 | 3.4 | 2.5 times | 77 of 100 | 76 | -18.6 percent |
| Janitorial services | 349 | 2.2 | 1.3 times | 55 of 100 | 113 | -6.9 percent |
| Landscaping services | 51 | 0.3 | 0.1 times | 84 of 100 | 4 | -1.9 percent |
| Physicians offices | 2,224 | 13.9 | 3.4 times | 84 of 100 | 132 | -16.9 percent |
| Dentists | 1,341 | 8.4 | 2.9 times | 84 of 100 | 44 | -9.2 percent |
| Full-service restaurants | 3,998 | 25 | 3.7 times | 42 of 100 | 1,495 | -10.8 percent |
| General automotive repair | 62 | 0.4 | 0.1 times | 85 of 100 | 3 | -15.1 percent |
| Beauty salons | 1,207 | 7.6 | 4 times | 84 of 100 | 89 | -8.8 percent |
Census County Business Patterns 2022 (employer locations only, so sole proprietors are not counted) against 2017. Typical county means the median county with 20,000 or more residents.
Three groups of trades
Law offices, beauty salons, restaurants, physician offices, real estate agents, dentists and accountants
Law offices are 7.6 times the typical county, and salons, restaurants and physician offices run between 3.4 and 4.0 times. A new entrant must choose a narrow specialty or a narrow area to be seen.
Residential remodelers, insurance agencies and janitorial services
These sit near the typical county in density, at about 1.0 to 1.3 times. The field is less crowded, so search work can focus on service pages instead of differentiation.
Roofing, landscaping, general auto repair, plumbing and heating and air conditioning, and electrical contractors
Roofing has only 6 employer locations, landscaping 51 and auto repair 62. The work still exists, so the firms doing it must be based in other counties, and they compete for Manhattan searches from outside.
Reading crowded trades
In the crowded group, the question is not whether customers exist but how a customer chooses. Law offices are the most crowded trade against the typical county, with 3,550 locations, and 445 of them have twenty or more staff, which means a solo practitioner in Manhattan is competing with large firms for the same search. Full-service restaurants number 3,998, with 1,495 of them at twenty or more staff, and salons number 1,207 with most under ten staff. Whatever the trade, a New York County customer sees dozens of options within a few blocks.
The response is specificity. A law office wins by naming a practice area and a neighborhood. A salon wins with a profile that shows fresh photos, current prices and recent reviews. A restaurant wins with accurate hours, a menu that loads quickly and a clear way to book. Search engine optimization here is less about a single page one position and more about showing up in the specific searches a customer actually types.
Reading scarce trades
Roofing counts 6 employer locations, which is 0.04 times the typical county, and landscaping counts 51. Plumbing, heating and air conditioning has 226 locations, or 0.44 times typical, and electrical contractors have 221. Buildings, roofs and boilers exist all the same, so a good deal of the work in New York County must be done by firms with locations in New Jersey, Brooklyn, Queens or the Bronx.
For a contractor outside the island, New York County is a market where the local competition is thin but the customer has real concerns: building access, insurance certificates, hours that avoid peak tolls and a crew that will arrive. Pages and profiles that answer those concerns directly can compete for searches where a nearby address is not available. Plumbing and heating and air conditioning also grew 3.2 percent since 2017, the fastest of the fifteen trades, while roofing fell by a third from 9 locations to 6.
New building
| Year | New residential units authorized |
|---|---|
| 2021 | 3,165 |
| 2022 | 4,337 |
| 2023 | 3,030 |
| 2024 | 4,467 |
| 2025 | 2,984 |
Census Building Permits Survey, new privately owned housing units authorized by permit.
What the permits add up to
Between 2,984 and 4,467 new residential units were authorized in each of the five years, against 913,058 housing units already standing in New York County. That is a very small addition each year, so most work for trades such as remodeling, plumbing, electrical and cleaning happens inside existing buildings, whether that is a prewar apartment on the Upper West Side or an older loft in SoHo.
It also explains why renovation and repair searches sit alongside new-home searches in importance. Residents who rent, about three in four households, usually deal with a landlord or building manager before booking a trade, so pages that explain how to coordinate with a building convert better than pages written for a homeowner.
How to use the table in an afternoon
Note the density against the typical county, the share of small firms and the change since 2017.
A crowded trade needs a narrow specialty or a narrow area, and a scarce one needs proof that you can reach the island.
Crowded trades usually begin with the Business Profile and reviews. Scarce trades begin with service pages that name the neighborhoods you serve.
The Census publishes County Business Patterns annually, and a change in a trade's count is a signal to revisit the plan.
Questions
Reading the trade table is part of planning and is not billed separately. What you pay for is the marketing that follows: $495 a month for 25 RankGuarantee™ landing pages, or Organic Growth at $1,495 (Silver, no website), $2,495 (Gold, managed website) or $3,495 (Platinum). Ads management is $895, $1,595 or $2,295, with ad spend extra, and nothing locks you in.
They come from County Business Patterns for 2022 and 2017, so they are survey-year snapshots and not live counts. Use them to understand structure, such as which trades are crowded, and not to count exact competitors today. Your own search results show the current picture.
Yes, but the target changes. Instead of aiming for the broadest term, aim for a specialty, a neighborhood or a type of customer where fewer rivals compete. Reviews, a strong profile and focused service pages matter more than volume.
It can be, if your business is outside the county and can reach it. Fewer firms based on the island means less local competition, but customers still need proof that you can arrive on time, enter their building and work legally.
Not because of one table. Plumbing, heating and air conditioning grew 3.2 percent and remodelers 1.6 percent, but that tells you little about your skills, your reputation or your costs. Use growth as a hint, not a plan.
Both are crowded, at 3.4 and 2.9 times the typical county, and both fell in count since 2017. Patients choose on map position, reviews and how soon they can book, so the Business Profile and online booking deserve the first attention.
We can describe the contrast using the same Census data, for example Brooklyn, Queens or the Bronx. The comparison is useful when you serve more than one borough, because crowding and customer habits often differ at the borough line.
Explore more
Get in Touch
Name your trade and your neighborhood, and we will say how crowded your field is on the island and what that means for the first piece of marketing. Call 610-825-4363 or email hello@getphound.com.
